4 Myths About Catholics and Mary You Probably Believe
Share
The figure of the Virgin Mary often sparks confusion and misunderstanding, especially concerning her role in Catholic faith. Some believe Catholics treat her like a goddess, while others might see her only as a Christmas figure. However, honoring Mary within Catholicism is biblical, historical, and deeply Christ-centered. This post will challenge common misconceptions and explore why Mary's veneration is not idolatry, drawing insights from "Pine Tree Catholic".
Myth 1: Catholics Worship Mary
This is completely false. Catholic theology makes a crucial distinction regarding the level of honor given. Worship, known as adoration or latria, is the highest form of honor and is reserved for God alone – the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. This level of devotion involves offering sacrifice, surrendering our entire selves, and acknowledging God as our creator and redeemer. No one else, not even Mary, receives this.
So, what about the honor given to Mary? The Church teaches:
- Latria: Worship due to God alone.
- Dulia: The veneration given to saints.
- Hyperdulia: A special kind of veneration given only to Mary because she is the Mother of God.
While these distinctions might seem like "splitting hairs," they have profound theological significance, protecting God's uniqueness while recognizing His work through human beings, particularly Mary. Scripture itself supports this, as Mary proclaims in Luke 1:48, "From now on all generations will call me blessed." She acknowledges God's extraordinary work in her, not claiming divinity.
Mary shines brightest as an intercessor. Catholics do not pray to her as if she is the source of grace. Instead, they ask for her prayers because of her closeness to Jesus, much like a queen mother in the Old Testament bringing the people's needs to the king. An example is the wedding at Cana, where Mary identified a need, brought it to Jesus, and He performed His first miracle. In essence, Catholics love and honor Mary, and ask for her prayers, because "she always says do whatever he tells you".
Myth 2: Catholics Think Mary is Equal to God
Nothing could be further from the truth. The Catholic Church teaches that Mary is a creature; she is fully human, like us in all things but sin, and absolutely dependent on the grace of God.
When Catholics call Mary the Mother of God (Theotokos in Greek), it's not because she is the origin of Jesus's divinity. This title refers to the person she bore. It was officially defined at the Council of Ephesus in 431 AD to protect the doctrine of Christ's divinity as one divine person. Therefore, the title "Mother of God" says more about Jesus than it does about Mary. Church Fathers like St. Irenaeus, St. Cyril, and St. Augustine show great love and praise for Mary, but always maintain her subordination to Christ; any honor she receives flows from His grace.
In fact, every Marian doctrine teaches something fundamental about Jesus:
- Her Immaculate Conception highlights the power of Christ's grace to save from sin.
- Her Assumption points to the destiny of all the faithful.
- Her Motherhood reflects the mystery of the Incarnation. At the heart of it all is always Jesus.
Myth 3: Marian Doctrines Were Just Made Up
Some might believe Marian doctrines were invented by "overzealous popes," but Catholic dogma doesn't work that way. Dogmas are not invented; they are discovered and unfolded through centuries of prayer, study, and reflection, guided by the Holy Spirit.
For example, the Immaculate Conception was proclaimed in 1848, and the Assumption in 1950. While critics might question why so late, both doctrines were beloved by the faithful long before their formal definition. St. Ambrose in the 4th century referred to Mary as a "virgin immune through grace from every stain of sin," and St. Augustine taught that because of her role, we should never speak of sin in the same sentence with Mary.
These teachings do not exalt Mary for her own sake; they exalt what God has done in her. As the Catechism states, "what the church believes about Mary is based on what it believes about Christ". The Church defines a dogma when it becomes necessary to protect the truth or affirm what the faithful have always believed—what is called the sensus fidelium or "sense of the faithful". Marian dogmas deepen the understanding of how God works in salvation history, rather than creating new theology.
Myth 4: Mary is a Mediator on the Same Level as Jesus
Absolutely not. Scripture is clear: Jesus is the one true mediator through His death and resurrection. He bridges the gap between humanity and God, and no one else could accomplish that.
However, this doesn't mean others cannot participate in His mediation by interceding for others. The Bible is full of examples of intercessory prayer: Abraham interceding for Sodom, Moses for Israel, and Paul asking believers to pray for one another.
Mary's role is similar. At Cana, she saw a need, brought it to Jesus, and trusted in His will. Her role is like "a mother in the court of a king; she doesn't command but she brings our needs before his throne". Her power is entirely dependent on Christ. When the Church calls her a Mediatrix, it doesn't mean she replaces Jesus; it means she shares in a unique and humble way in His mission of bringing grace to the world. This concept fits within the broader Catholic belief in the communion of saints, where the body of Christ is united in love, and believers pray for each other across heaven and earth.
Conclusion
In summary:
- Catholics do not worship Mary; they honor her.
- They do not equate her with God; she is a humble servant full of grace.
- Marian dogmas were not invented; they reflect what the Church has always believed.
- Mary's role as intercessor is powerful but always points us to Christ.
- Mary's only mission is this: to lead us to Jesus. She is a spiritual mother, an intercessor, and a model of faith, but always, always in service to Jesus Christ our Lord and Savior.